Group+3

Write your answers below. Don't forget to type your **first** name so others can respond to your thoughts. Try to remember the example we gave you. Give evidence from the book for the way you think.

When you have completed your response go to: http://teacher.scholastic.com/activities/swyar/write.asp and write a review. Use Ctrl A, Ctrl C to select all and copy to place your review into a word document. Save as City of Ember review. Check out [|Learn How to Write a Book Review with Rodman Philbrick] for help with your review.

Question: How might the story be different if it had happened somewhere else (or in a different time period)? If it happened somewhere else it would have been a total different story. Well it depends what kind of place. If it was not underground it would have been totally different story. It would have been totally different because one thing you think about a lot in this book is if or if not underground and if it was not underground how would the city have no lights/sky or sun? And the city would have to be some sort of a magical place like a fairy tale. If it was in a place like Vancouver it would not work because they would not be running out of supplies and… Jessica T. If it happened somewhere else, I think it would be really different because the instructions wouldn’t lead upper ground because the city might not be under ground in the first place. If they weren’t under ground, they wouldn’t have any problems with the light because if they weren’t underground, they would have the sun for light instead. So they wouldn’t really need instructions to get out. Unless there was a problem like shortage on food, water and other necessary supplies, so the story would be a really different story. Rigby K.